Monday, May 01, 2006

Annual rate of growth in the expat labor force in the UAE: 17 percent

Gulf News:
The number of expatriate workers in the UAE was 2,738,000 in 2005. The number is a 17 per cent increase over 2004.
That's a big number. It tells you that the Ministry of Labour does not make it difficult for a firm to bring in expat workers.

Demand for labor in the UAE has increased. But the UAE is a small player in the worldwide labor market. So an increase in demand translates into an increase in employment with little if any upward pressure on wages. (Exceptions to the rule would include narrow job categories such as experienced construction managers.)

Translation: The UAE faces a highly elastic, if not perfectly elastic supply of labor from abroad. There is a vast army of workers who would be glad to come to the UAE at terms that represent an improvement over salary and working conditions in their home country.

Thus, if wages and working conditions are to improve in the UAE the laws of economics tell us it will be because wages and working conditions improve in the countries where the UAE recruits labor. This is happening in places like India where economic liberalization has triggered a growing economy. But it is not in other countries. The UAE has other countries to turn to for cheap labor.

Ironically, the Indian miracle has also contributed to the growth in the world demand for oil that has resulted in the increase in the UAE's oil revenues.

Labels: , , , ,

Thursday, April 27, 2006

UAE nationals in the workforce - views aired

Khaleej Times reports. The indented material below is from the article.
Interestingly, some businessmen remain critical of the current emiratisation process alleging that a large number of UAE nationals are not serious about doing the jobs offered to them.
. . .
Raja Al Gurg, Chairperson of Dubai Businesswomen Council, ... said, "We need to chalk out a mechanism to encourage nationals to be serious when it comes to taking up jobs. Large numbers of nationals are not serious at all...they take up a job and then simply quit few days later."
Nationals are wealthier than expats. Under standard economic assumptions about human preferences, when you are wealthier you will have a higher reservation wage - that is, you demand a larger reward for joining the labor force. Employers are motivated by profit, and for workers of the same quality employers will offer the same nondiscriminatory pay. The compensation offered attracts the number of workers the firm requires. As it happens it is below the reservation wage of most nationals.
There was also some similar criticisms at yesterday's meeting dealing with the country's 'educational output' — not being compatible with the requirements of the labour market.
True. The output of government schools for nationals needs improvement, and, in general, it is inferior to the output of private schools. In my judgment, government expenditure per pupil is sufficient. The trouble comes from two major factors.

The first is that schools are mismanaged and/or have are subject to government rules and regulations that often make the job of school principles and teachers more difficult.

The second factor is weak incentives. Too often a young national's future has little connection to merit, to how well he or she does in school. This is not a problem schools can solve, but it does constrain what schools can achieve with the raw material - students - they are given.
Brigadier Saeed bin Beleilah, Director-General of Dubai Naturalisation and Residency Department (DNRD), said: "As long as employment directors at banks are not UAE nationals, the emiratisation process will remain a cosmetic one; nationals are given jobs with low salaries or the percentage of nationals employed would be tampered with in league with some companies that are assigned to carry out certain jobs".
That's a long sentence. Let's start with the last bit, "percentage of nationals employed would be tampered with in league with some companies that are assigned to carry out certain jobs." He is referring to one of the ways that employers game requirements to have a certain minimum percentage of their employees be nationals. One way to get around the rules is to take some tasks that would have been insourced and to outsource them. Would requiring firms to have HR Directors who were nationals create an effective policing mechanism to prevent gaming of the emiratization rules? I doubt it.

Requiring firms to have HR directors who were nationals would not mean nationals would be offered higher salaries. Senior management still sets salaries, not the HR director, and senior management defines what authority the HR director has. In the extreme case the formal HR director position would become a token, and the company would have a shadow HR director running the show. Besides, all private employers in the UAE have majority national ownership. That is a convenient fact to omit. If the owner is a national what difference will it make if the HR director is a national? Especially if the HR director is a member of the family.
Obaid Al Jaber, Chairman of the Board of Directors of Al Jaber Group, highlighted the problem of nationals' employment and their inclination to switch to other companies after getting the necessary training. Unlike expatriates who find it difficult to change their sponsorships, nationals can switch jobs easily.
Mr. Al Jaber echoes a point of view I have frequently expressed here at The Emirates Economist. The inequality of job change rights between nationals and expats works to the disadvantage of nationals. For the same compensation and same quality of work, employers will prefer to hire the worker who has less freedom to walk away from his or her contract with the employer. It is the government that has created the preference firms have for expats.
Reacting to criticism voiced during the meeting against the skyrocketing fees imposed by the ministry last year, the Labour Minister said only erring firms felt the pinch. "Companies committed to the rules concerning nationalities and nationalisation do not actually pay high fees and are exempt from the bank guarantee," he stated. He said the number of violations was "shocking". Fines collected, he pointed out, amounted to Dh153 million last year.
Part of the reason for the large amount of fines collected is that there was a change in enforcement of existing rules. Firms were accustomed to violating the rules and did so. They were surprised when the ministry began to enforce its own rules. We can expect firms to adjust by finding ways around the rules.

What this last quote also points to is that there are a load of rules and regulations regarding labor. Too many to have a vibrant labor market. But not enough, evidently, to prevent private sector employment from being over 95% expat. Indeed, as I pointed out above, the rules are part of the explanation of the 95%.

Labels: , , , ,

Monday, April 10, 2006

Burning their bridges - no exit

Expat workers in the UAE have no exit. Once you have signed on with an employer it is next to impossible - particularly in the low-wage sector - to legally change jobs. You can quit, but quitting has little purpose if you have no where else to market your talents except to go back to where you came from - assuming you have the resources to pay for the ticket home.

Thus, if your employer does not live up to his or her side of the contract with you, then you are likely to stay with them anyway in the hope that you will eventually get your due. In contrast, if you could easily change jobs then you would change employers if your current employer failed to respect the contract. Meaning, your employer has every incentive to treat you well if you can credibly threaten to leave. Which explains why so many employers in the UAE fail in their responsibilities to pay their workers on time or to provide them the living and working conditions they promised.

One of the ways that unions might be a positive force for employers is to give workers voice. When workers have voice employers get advance notice that workers may be about to exit for better job opportunities that have arisen in the labor market either because wages in the market have increased or the firm is unwittingly doing something that makes work there relatively unattractive.

In the case of the UAE labor market institutions - no exit by individuals - voice and collective action are all low-wage workers have, if they have anything. Thus, it is not surprising that they are driven to take collective action.

Recently the UAE announced that unions would be formed: Labourers will be allowed to form unions. Quote,
We’re going to have one union, with separate representatives for the construction, fishing, agriculture and other industries,” Labour Minister Ali Al Kaabi told The Associated Press. . . . “The law will control how strikes will be conducted. It will outline rights, the do’s and don’ts. There will be a labour representative who will be our point of contact. It will make contact with the labourers much easier.”
I believe that's what you call a company union. This move may be window dressing. Or it may be part of a pattern of central control of labor movements (in both senses of that phrase). UAE workers don't need a collective labor movement. They need individual job mobility. But that would involve trusting the Invisible Hand. Too scary.

Here's the latest on what the workers are working on: Taipei Times - archives. Some quotes:
The construction workers, packed together inside the tiny hut in one of Dubai's harsh desert labor camps, are breaking the most fundamental of all the draconian laws governing immigrants within the United Arab Emirates (UAE) -- they are holding a union meeting, a practice that is banned in all but one of the Gulf States.
. . .
According to 36-year-old Kamal (not his real name), who spearheaded the Burj Dubai protest, more needs to be done.

"These protests received attention in the press and were forgotten about, we need to do more. I was involved in a sit-down protest on the motorway last month, but the police came along with sticks and beat us on the backs and head. Many of my friends were hospitalized and deported," he said.

"The riot got a lot of attention, but things haven't improved for us. We already know what we have to do next, we take our protests into the malls and to the beaches," Kamal said.

"Our situation needs international attention and only by unsettling tourists can we achieve this. They need to see how desperate we really are," he said.
Kamal certainly knows how to identify the soft underbelly that feeds Dubai. A real economic savant.

A classic stratagem to increase your ferocity in battle and intimidate your opponent into concession is to burn your bridges behind you so can't exit and you have to stand and fight. Ironically, it's not the workers that have done the conflagration honors, it is the UAE government labor policies that have driven the workers to collective action. No exit.

For the Taipei Time link thanks go to Axonsax posting at UAE community blog.

Labels: , , ,

Thursday, April 06, 2006

You don't say?
Inference by process of elimination

Item: Gulfnews: Drunken youths rape and assault women

Item: Gulfnews: drunk driver kills workers on break

The ladies and gentlemen of the UAE journalism community are, I infer, well aware that omission can be a very effective means of telegraphing what you mean and still stay within bounds of the defamation code. Simply always report nationality unless a UAE national is involved.

Ergo, the unidentified delinquent raping drunk driver person is very likely to be of the nationality that is one that is almost always omitted when it would be shameful or embarrassing. It is a sign of progress, but adds no other information, that sometimes it is expressly stated that the suspect is a UAE national; the first item above is one example. Now if we can only get rid of initials and name names of rapists, alleged or convicted, and not just the names of their victims.

This signaling equilibrium stuff ain't as hard as economists make it out to be is it? Sometimes it's pretty costless to tell the goats from the sheep. Especially when everybody knows that everybody knows that everybody knows how this game is played.

On the power of common knowledge: There are three persons. There are three hats on their three heads. Hats may be either white or black. No one knows their hat color. I say to all three, raise your hand if you see a white hat. Everyone raises their hand. Then I say to all three, raise your hand if you know the color of your hat. There is a pause. Finally, one raises his hand. What color is his hat? Hint: common knowledge is created when the three see the responses to the first question, "do you see a white hat?"

Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, April 04, 2006

The Produce of Polygyny

What does polygyny produce? Is it bare branches or is it low-hanging fruit?

Jonathan Rauch writing in Reason, "One Man, Many Wives, Big Problems: The social consequences of polygamy are bigger than you think", puts himself in the shoes of the man who can't find a wife because some men have several wives. That man is classified as a bare branch: no fruit of his loins.

Rauch even suggests, darkly, that polygyny produces bitter lonelyboys who ripen into Jihadists. Perhaps. Perhaps he should wonder what he is implying about the rage of black women in the U.S. whose most likelies are behind bars.

As we have posted on before, Tim Harford (Undercover Economist) takes a look at polygyny from the perspective of the woman. When one guy can marry several Anna Nicole Smiths, that leaves lots of marriageable guys for the remaining women. Looked at through the lens of supply and demand, polygyny is good for the disstaff side.

Can what is good for half of humankind be bad for society as a whole? I suggest Rauch at least give this some thought.

Probably what polygynous societies do produce on the male side is the same thing single gender prisons produce. Seed that falls on fallow ground.

Via: Fark, of course.

TAGS: , , ,

Labels: , , , , ,

Thursday, March 30, 2006

UAE: Address Abuse of Migrant Workers (Human Rights Watch, 29-3-2006)

Quote:
Human Rights Watch recently conducted a fact-finding mission on the conditions of migrant workers in the UAE and will be releasing its full findings in the next few months.
There is much in this report that is accurate. There is much in this report that is embarrassing to the UAE. But much of what is embarrassing is only embarrassing because many good-intentioned people believe the UAE should be ashamed of the way it treats low-skilled immigrant workers while in fact the workers like it that way.

If those people could carry out their good intentions many of the workers they intend to help would in fact either lose their jobs or see some of their salaries diverted to be spent on things they would rather not buy like better living conditions or safer working conditions.

There is a reason that the UAE has the highest net immigration in the world: it is the land of opportunity for many impoverished people who prefer working to being trapped in their home country, and who would prefer to trade higher wages to better living and working conditions. It's revealed preference - no one is forcing them to come the UAE, and if workers really did prefer better living conditions innovative firms could offer better conditions at lower salaries and hire workers for a lower total cost than existing firms.

There is a direct parallel in the working conditions of the grandfathers and great grandfathers of the citizens of the UAE today. Many of those men worked in the pearl diving industry and lived in squalid conditions at sea for months, not seeing their families, and eating retched food. In the profit-sharing arrangement of that time those awful conditions were the choice of the workers collective.

Just as in the time when pearl diving thrived what was most difficult to enforce was payment of what was due to the workers. With pearl diving you might be able to verify the catch by opening the pearl bearing oysters together. But there remained the problem of the unfaithful agent who sold the pearls and may have taken a hidden side payment from a pearl buyer cheating the divers out of some of their share of the revenue.*

Likewise, today, we hear frequent stories of workers not being paid when promised and in some cases not being paid at all. In a country that does not allow workers to change jobs to protect themselves from dishonest or incompetent employers, 80 labor inspectors for something like 2,000,000 expatriate workers is a ridiculously small number. Either increase the number of inspectors considerably and give them significant enforcement power, or - better - let workers change jobs. Do one or the other or both. But don't do virtually nothing.

samuraisam draws our attention to this quote:
"To link what happened [protests] to the construction boom in the country - which represents a sign of progress in the region - or to negotiations on free trade is really devious, illogical and insane," labor minister Ali Al Kaabi told the Al Khaleej daily.
As the reader will infer, I agree with the labor minister that report contains much that is illogical. Labeling it "insane" is too strong, especially when there is some truth to the abuses enumerated.

*Ironically, the stories of these heroic men are best told in a book that is banned in the UAE, Shaikhdoms of Eastern Arabia by Peter Lienhardt. Probably it is banned because of a few lines in the author's acknowledgments that is interpreted as defaming a royal. Or perhaps it is the discussion of piracy in the early 20th century. If you are interested you can probably read some of those bits by following the link above and then going to explore.

Labels: , , ,

Monday, March 27, 2006

The Burj Dubai Labor Riot: Tuesday 21 Mar 2006

At the cusp of this blog's recent Yemeni hiatus a riot broke out at the site of the construction site of what is projected to be the tallest building in the world. If you've arrived here looking for coverage of the story, I direct you to this post at DM Blog where BD is on the case. It's link rich with newspaper accounts. And BD adds his own excellent analysis. He's also provided an extensive amount of background on the unskilled labor sector in the UAE.

BD asks, why the Burj Dubai, where the workers are comparatively better paid and are provided better working and living conditions. His answer:
This unrest was, therefore, not about the usual issue of workers not receiving salaries for months or intolerable living conditions. Why then did the protest erupt in violence? On the face of it, it is rather ironic. It appears in fact, that the uprising was more spontaneous than planned. I would speculate that there was in essence a high degree of frustration over the transport and security issues which was ignited on account of the large numbers involved. I would surmise that this was the critical factor. What was unique in this instance was the combination of both a high level of frustration and large numbers gathered at the massive construction site. It does not represent a typical scenario.
My thoughts, too, ran quickly to why this site and not others. Probably BD is on to something in focusing on the scale of the project and the numbers involved. Most mobs are not far from being unruly because there is safety in numbers. Are there ring leaders to be singled out for punishment? Perhaps. But it is not in the interest of the owners to punish all the protesters - this simply converts a costly work stoppage initiated by the workers into a stoppage prolonged by the prosecutors.

It is in the owner's interest to see work resume by those workers. And why those workers? First by virtue of the sheer size of the project the workers cannot be replaced wholesale. Second, as they work on the project floor to floor the workers are gaining skills in doing the work faster and better.

The workers know this. The maximum the owner is willing to pay the workers is rising. A worker's protest is a way for the workers to extract more from the firm.

As BD wrote "this does not represent a typical scenario." In the typical situation in the Gulf, if workers strike to gain some of the economic rents flowing to the employer, the employer can rather costlessly replace the worker.

UPDATE - I see I'm getting visitors via this link: Pajamas Media: The other immigrant scene. The title of that post is a reference to what has become a hot political issue in the U.S., illegal immigration (see this coverage). If you conclude from this that the U.S. has a recent history of being tight-assed about immigration, consider this amazing world map showing net immigration by country. The U.S. remains the land of opportunity in both the demand (people wish to come to America) and supply (an open door policy) senses.

UPDATE 2 - See, also, Migrants and the Middle East - Welcome to the other side of Dubai which gets to the nub of the workers' issues. It's not clear who is expropriating who:
The interior ministry began negotiations with the labourers but were left somewhat bewildered by this very un-Dubai mood of militancy. "They have no right to continue this strike. I don't know why they don't realise that," said Lieutenant-Colonel Rashid Bakhit Al Jumairi, a ministry investigator.

"They came back to the site, but they still refuse to work. The workers are demanding overtime pay, better medical care and humane treatment from their foremen. The companies have agreed to some of the demands. But the workers agreed to their employment conditions when they signed."

A carpenter from Andhra Pradesh in India, Mangal Prasad, said the action was taken as a last resort. "We just want to be treated like human beings. The way some of foremen behave towards us is very bad. If we complain they say we will get sent back. This is wrong," he said.
"We have also got to work much longer hours than we were contracted to because they want everything finished quickly. So why shouldn't we get overtime pay? That's what happens everywhere else. Most of us aren't saving money at all. We are still paying back the loan we took to get here."
Thanks to the Canadian Expat Countertenor for the link.

UPDATE 3 - Welcome to Instapundit readers. Glad to have you drop in.

Labels: , , , ,

Wednesday, January 25, 2006

Emiratization database :: Gulf News

Quote (scroll to end of Gulf News article):
During a meeting held in Abu Dhabi between the UAE Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs, General Pension and Social Security Authority, Abu Dhabi Retirement Pension and Benefits Fund and Tanmia Dr Khalid Al Khazraji, Undersecretary at the Ministry of Health, highlighted the resolution and system adopted to facilitate the creation of a comprehensive database of UAE nationals and GCC employees in private sector.
Actually, this is a pretty big step. Without this integration it is not possible for Tanmia to determine whether an employer is meeting emiratization targets. Every working Emirati is a member of the pension system whether they are working in the public or the private sector. The pension authority's database has the information needed to track where Emiratis are working.

UPDATE: Labour minister vows to crackdown on the company that created sham jobs to meet emiratization targets.

Labels: , , , ,